Home  >  5 Pack Tastings

5 Pack Tastings

Welcome to Gotham’s 5-Pack Tastings! Here you get to choose from the 5-Packs below and make sure you really like them before you buy the box.

Our philosophy on the Tastings: We call it a tasting because the first one you try is an introduction to the brand. The second one allows you to determine consistency and really decide if you love it.

By the third cigar, you are then enjoying it and guess what? There is still two more to puff on or share with friends. This really gives you the best value for your money and every tasting comes

With a free GOTHAM CIGAR cutter!

5 Pack Tastings

       

Customer Reviews

FACSTM5PK
You cant beat this price.
I tried these out for the 12.99 and I was impressed good smoke and great price. Medium body cigar
- Lance Berry, MS
 
FACSTM5PK
Gotham Factory Seconds
These cigars were not to my taste having a very robust flavor with a heavy and persistent after taste. Wrappers were cracked and brittle upon opening the package which may have been the reason they are seconds.
 

AF858T5
Great Smoke
Excellent cigar for the price. Great taste and flavor
 
AF858T5
A perfect 45 minutes
My favorite general smoke. Very consistant and flavorful to the end.
 
AF858T5
Arturo Fuente 858
Excellent Service!
- Kris Vardas, CA
 
AF858T5
After Dinner Smoke
Nice flavor. Reasonably priced. Enjoyed it very much. This is a nice After Dinner cigar that I would recommend to all my friends.
Stoni
 
AF858T5
Arturo Fuente 5 Pack
Above average smoke and typical of Arturo Fuente. Even and smooth draw. I have always liked curley-heads but believe these are a better cigar. Worth a try.
 
AF858T5
Super Deal
Fantastic price for the 5 cigars. These cigars usually run $5 or $6 a piece so its like half priced and the cigar cutter was a nice surprise to get as well.
- Marlon Wright, OH
 
AF858T5
great buy
I love that you guys offer 5 packs on the Fuente 858! great gift idea, and it comes in a nice bag along with a free cutter!
- Gene Sanchez, MN
 

AFCHTT5
good every day cigars
fuente makes a real winner with the chats these rock!
- Willy Tavaras, IL
 

ASHMAG5
Ashton is overpriced
ok cigar but really too pricey for what they give you. I dont care for it.
- Terry Elso, IN
 

GCTRP5
Glad I tried them
I am a casual cigar smoker and found these very enjoyable.
 
GCTRP5
these are high end
I went to my local store and they want 25 a piece for these cigars. CRAZY
- Luis Gonzalez, FL
 

RPDROB5
RP does it again
The decade is well worth the wait one of my favorite cigars! love the robusto.
- Tim Arrington, MI
 

RPDTRP5
Bad packaging
Havent tried the cigars yet, but not happy about the packaging - plastic bag. I thought it would be in a wood box.
 
RPDTRP5
Solid
Nice draw good smoke! I really enjoy these after dinner with a cognac.
- Tom Livingston, MA
 

GHBCONRL5
gurka house blend
they are exquisite!!
 
GHBCONRL5
gurka house blend
got them for my husband,,he said they were good...likes the brand gurka anyway.
 

GHBHABTOR5
cigars
The cigars that were delivered were dried out and the wrapper began to unwrap as I smoked the cigar. Ive had better and was disappointed.
 
Please share your thoughts and experiences with our Cigar community.
You can review any product below by clicking the Reviews link.

Item # Image Description Our Price
Reviews  (2)


FACSTM5PK
FACTORY SECONDS TORO MADURO 5 PACK
FACTORY SECONDS TORO MADURO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Pack
Size: 6 x 53

Suggested Retail Price: $25.00
 
In Stock
Just Landed
$12.99


Reviews  (0)


ACKK5
ACID KUBA KUBA 5 PACK
ACID KUBA KUBA 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Sumatra
Size: 5 x 54

 
In Stock
$25.00


Reviews  (0)


ASH8985PK
ASHTON 898 5 PACK
ASHTON 898 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 6 1/2 x 44

 
In Stock
$32.50


Reviews  (0)


AFHSS5
ARTURO FUENTE HEMINGWAY SHORT STORY 5 PACK
ARTURO FUENTE HEMINGWAY SHORT STORY 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 4 x 49

 
In Stock
$25.99


Reviews  (7)


AF858T5
ARTURO FUENTE 858 5 PACK
ARTURO FUENTE 858 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 6 x 47

 
In Stock
$20.00


Reviews  (1)


AFCHTT5
ARTURO FUENTE CHATEAU 5 PACK
ARTURO FUENTE CHATEAU 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 4 1/2 x 50

 
In Stock
$13.64


Reviews  (1)


ASHMAG5
ASHTON MAGNUM 5 PACK
ASHTON MAGNUM 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 x 50

 
In Stock
$32.50


Reviews  (2)


GCTRP5
GURKHA CREST TORPEDO 5 PACK
GURKHA CREST TORPEDO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 6 x 52

Suggested Retail Price: $125.00
 
In Stock
Specials
$49.99


Reviews  (1)


RPDROB5
ROCKY PATEL DECADE ROBUSTO 5 PACK
ROCKY PATEL DECADE ROBUSTO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 x 50

 
In Stock
$42.50


Reviews  (2)


RPDTRP5
ROCKY PATEL DECADE TORPEDO 5 PACK
ROCKY PATEL DECADE TORPEDO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 6 1/2 x 52

 
In Stock
$42.50


Reviews  (2)


GHBCONRL5
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT ROBUSTO LARGO 5 PACK
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT ROBUSTO LARGO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Connecticut
Size: 5.5 x 50

Suggested Retail Price: $35.00
 
In Stock
$19.99


Reviews  (0)


GHBCONROB5
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT ROBUSTO 5 PACK
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT ROBUSTO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Connecticut
Size: 5 x 50

Suggested Retail Price: $35.00
 
In Stock
$19.99


Reviews  (0)


GHBCONTOR5
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT TORO 5 PACK
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT TORO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Connecticut
Size: 6 x 50

Suggested Retail Price: $35.00
 
In Stock
$19.99


Reviews  (0)


GHBCONTRP5
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT TORPEDO 5 PACKS
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND CONNECTICUT TORPEDO 5 PACKS
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Connecticut
Size: 6.8 x 52

Suggested Retail Price: $35.00
 
In Stock
$19.99


Reviews  (1)


GHBHABTOR5
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND HABANO TORO 5 PACK
GURKHA HOUSE BLEND HABANO TORO 5 PACK
Quantity: 5 Cigars
Wrapper: Habano
Size: 6 x 52

Suggested Retail Price: $55.00
 
In Stock
Will be shipped via: FREE GROUND SERVICE (ORDER OVER $150) -
$40.00



 Recently Reviewed Items




 
Cart
Items 0  |  Sub Total $0.00
  Checkout
About Us Site Map Account Login Testimonials Gotham Winners Wish List Company Policies Contact Us FAQ