Explore Our 90+ Rated Premium Cigars handpicked

Indulging in a cigar that has earned a 90+ rating from Cigar Aficionado is akin to savoring a masterpiece—each puff delivers exceptional flavor, craftsmanship, and an unparalleled smoking experience. At Gotham Cigars, we take pride in offering a curated selection of these top-rated cigars, ensuring our customers enjoy only the finest.

Understanding Cigar Ratings

Cigar Aficionado, a leading authority in the cigar industry, employs a meticulous 100-point rating system to evaluate cigars. A score of 90 or above signifies an "outstanding" cigar, recognized for its superior construction, flavor complexity, and overall excellence.

Explore Our 90+ Rated Premium Cigars

Here are some of the exceptional cigars available in our collection:

Rocky Patel Vintage 1990
This cigar features a 12-year-old Honduran Broadleaf wrapper, offering a medium-bodied smoke with notes of earth, cedar, and a hint of espresso. It's a testament to Rocky Patel's commitment to quality and has been a favorite among aficionados for years.

Gotham Cigars

Alec Bradley Project 40 Robusto
Part of the acclaimed Project 40 line, this cigar delivers a rich, flavorful experience with a blend of Nicaraguan fillers and a Nicaraguan wrapper. It's designed to enhance relaxation and enjoyment, aligning with the concept that 40% of your happiness is within your control.

Gotham Cigars

Alec Bradley Magic Toast Toro
This unique blend combines Honduran and Nicaraguan tobaccos, resulting in a medium to full-bodied smoke with notes of cocoa, cedar, and a subtle sweetness. The name 'Magic Toast' comes from a special moment in the tobacco fields, making it a cigar with a story.

Gotham Cigars

La Gloria Cubana Serie R Esteli
A Nicaraguan puro, this cigar boasts a full-bodied profile with rich flavors of pepper, earth, and a touch of leather. It's a bold choice for those seeking a robust smoking experience.

Gotham Cigars

Ashton Virgin Sun Grown Robusto
Known for its full-bodied strength and depth, this cigar features a blend of aged Dominican tobaccos wrapped in a dark Ecuadorian leaf, offering notes of espresso, leather, and spices. It's a luxurious choice for the discerning smoker.

Gotham Cigars

Why Choose 90+ Rated Cigars?

• Exceptional Quality: These cigars are crafted with the finest tobaccos and undergo rigorous quality control to ensure a superior smoking experience.
• Complex Flavor Profiles: Expect a harmonious balance of flavors, providing a rich and satisfying smoke from start to finish.
• Prestige and Recognition: Smoking a 90+ rated cigar aligns you with the preferences of seasoned aficionados and industry experts.

Enhance Your Collection

Incorporating 90+ rated cigars into your humidor not only elevates your smoking experience but also adds a touch of prestige to your collection. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a moment of relaxation, these cigars are sure to impress.

Explore More at Gotham Cigars

Our commitment to quality ensures that we offer a diverse range of top-rated cigars to suit every palate. Visit our 90+ Rated Premium Cigars page to discover more exceptional options and elevate your smoking experience today.

Note: Availability of specific cigars may vary. Please check our website for the most current inventory.