Subscribe & Save 5% on hundreds of items!

Gotham's Exclusive Cigars

Exclusive blends, house favorites, and New York-inspired cigars crafted for smokers who want something different.

Shop Exclusives Explore the Brands

Crafted from Experience.
Chosen for Everyday Enjoyment.

For over 25 years, Gotham Cigars has worked with cigar makers, listened to customers, and built a collection for every kind of smoker.

Gotham's Exclusive Cigars bring that experience into our own lineup of cigars: unique blends, approachable value, and styles made for real cigar moments.

How We Disrupted the $15 Cigar?

Traditional brands route through Factory, Exporter, Distributor, Retailer to You at $15.00/stick — Gotham goes Factory to Gotham's Exclusive Cigars to You for less than $4/stick.

We don't spend millions on magazine ads. We put that money back into the quality of our leaf. You get the same long filler tobacco used by well-known brands without the retail markup.

Find Your Gotham Exclusive Cigar

5 Boroughs Cigars

5 Boroughs Cigars

A premium Gotham cigar inspired by New York's boroughs and crafted for boutique-quality smoking.

Explore Brand
Flatbush Cigar Co.

Flatbush Cigar Co.

Brooklyn-inspired cigars with bold character, craftsmanship, and approachable value.

Explore Brand
Gotham House Blend

Gotham House Blend

An approachable everyday smoke from Gotham's own house blend, made for regular cigar moments.

Explore Brand
Flywheel Cigars

Flywheel Cigars

Smooth, balanced cigars made for moments of pause, reflection, and simple pleasure.

Explore Brand

Choose by Experience

I want bold Brooklyn character.Flatbush Cigar Co. ›
I want something with complexity and flavor.5 Boroughs Cigars ›
I want an affordable house cigar.Gotham House Blend ›
I want smooth everyday luxury.Flywheel Cigars ›

Quality Without the Guesswork

Gotham Exclusives are made for smokers who want something dependable, flavorful, and different from the usual stuff.

  • Crafted with Purpose — built from real long-filler tobacco, not shortcuts.
  • Made for Real Smokers — everyday sticks for everyday moments.
  • Exclusive to Gotham — you won't find these blends anywhere else.
Only at GothamCrafted with PurposeFewer Layers, More ValueMade for Real SmokersExclusive to Gotham

Inspired by New York. Crafted with Purpose.

5 Boroughs has the strongest handmade, “labor of love” story.

Explore the Brand

Featured Gotham Exclusives

Oliva Serie G Churchill 5-Pack
Add to Cart
Size: 7 x 50
$45.00
$39.79
The Oliva Serie G Churchill 5-Pack brings together craftsmanship, balance, and bold flavor in one refined collection. Each cigar is handcrafted in Nicaragua using premium-aged Nicaraguan tobaccos,...
Tyson 2.0 Undisputed Maduro 6 x 54 box
Add to Cart
Size: 6 x 54
$285.00
$199.99
Tyson 2.0 Undisputed Maduro 6 x 54 delivers a bold and powerful smoking experience with deep complexity and a smooth finish! Wrapped in a dark and oily Maduro wrapper, this full-bodied cigar is...
5 Boroughs 212 Toro
Choose Options
Size: 6 x 50
$55.99
$45.99
5 Boroughs 212 Toro is a mild to medium bodied smoke handmade at the boutique Tabacalera Pages factory in Nicaragua. Each cigar features a three region long filler blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos...
Flatbush Stoop 526 Churchill bundle
Choose Options
Size: 7 x 50
$49.50
$38.50
Flatbush Stoop 526 Churchill is a medium bodied cigar featuring a two region blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos from the fertile soils of Condega and Jalapa and a Nicaraguan Habano binder. The...
Back Alley Cigarillos White Grape
Choose Options

Back Alley Cigarillos White Grape

Size: 4 1/2 x 27
$29.99
$19.99
Back Alley Cigarillos White Grape are a new and exciting cigarillo made in the Dominican Republic using a blend of carefully aged tobaccos rolled in a natural homogenized leaf wrapper.  The...
Back Alley Cigarillos Blue Vanilla
Choose Options

Back Alley Cigarillos Blue Vanilla

Size: 4 1/2 x 27
$29.99
$19.99
Back Alley Cigarillos Blue Vanilla are a new and exciting cigarillo made in the Dominican Republic using a blend of carefully aged tobaccos rolled in a natural homogenized leaf wrapper.  The...

What Gotham Customers Say

“I used to only smoke $15 Padrons. The 5 Boroughs Maduro is the first cigar I've found that gives me that same complexity for a fraction of the cost.”

– Michael S.

“The Flatbush Toro is a beast. Great construction, thick smoke, and a kick that stays smooth. My new Friday night staple.”

– James L.

“If you aren't smoking the House Blend while you mow the lawn or work in the garage, you're wasting money. It's the best value in the industry.”

– Robert T.

Shop the Full Collection

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Flatbush Stoop 526 Gordo bundle Flatbush Stoop 526 Gordo stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view
    Size: 6 x 60
    Now: $37.99 - $39.99
    Flatbush Stoop 526 Gordo is a medium bodied cigar featuring a two region blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos from the fertile soils of Condega and Jalapa and a Nicaraguan Habano binder. The finishing touch is a Mexican San Andres Maduro wrapper that...
    Now: $37.99 - $39.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $37.99 - $39.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Out of stock
    5 Boroughs Bowery Gordo 5 Boroughs Bowery Gordo bundle
    Quick view
    Size: 6 x 60
    Now: $47.49 - $49.99
    5 Boroughs Bowery Gordo is a medium bodied smoke handmade at the boutique Tabacalera Pages factory in Nicaragua. Each cigar features a three region long filler blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos from the fertile regions of Condega, Jalap and Esteli...
    Now: $47.49 - $49.99
    Out of stock Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $47.49 - $49.99
    Subtotal:
    Out of stock
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

Frequently Asked Questions

Why can't I find these at my local store?

Because these are Gotham Exclusives. By selling them directly to you, we eliminate the additional markup and keep the value where it belongs.

Are these made with premium long-filler?

Yes. These are 100% handmade with long-filler tobacco. They are not “seconds” or “sandwich” cigars. They are boutique-grade batches for a quality smoking experience.

Which one should I try first?

For variety, go with 5 Boroughs. For strength, go with Flatbush. For value, go with the House Blend. Or, grab our Discovery Sampler to try all three.

Ships to the Continental
U.S. and Canada
21+ Age
Verification Required
Damage Support Within
30 Business Days