The shaft gives off fruity nuances alongside a drizzling of pepper and maybe a basic earthy note. Cold draw presents a barnyard character with a little pepper on the side and the same earthy note on the wrapper. The draw is the perfect milkshake consistency.

In truth, I have had delicious cigars that have spoken boldly right from the cold draw. My Real Nicaraguan is very subtle so far, but my hopes are up.

First Third

The very first draw introduces natural tobacco notes backed by a basic earthy nuance. There is a shy fruity note on the finish along with implicit sweetness in the back of my palate. Pepper kicks in followed by an orange citrus note. Butter and sweetness kick down the door as I take more draws. And I begin to relax as I watch my cigar take shape.

As the first third settles, desert sweetness hauling notes of toffee, baking spice, cinnamon, butter and that orangey tang dominate my palate. In the background are basic tobacco characters garnished with dashes of white peppery deliciousness. Retrohale speaks of graham cracker soaked in implicit salty butter.

This is awesome. Draw and burn are all above reproach. The ash is a beautiful salt and pepper mast; actually a lot more salt than pepper. Strength is a medium that is already threatening to revolt. I literally can't wait to see what's in store for the mid third.

Mid Third

An emerging caramel sweetness introduces the mid third. This addition marries indescribably well with the baking spice, cinnamon, white pepper, and natural tobacco sweetness that is already on the palate.

As the mid third progresses, the flavour characters shift. Earthiness and natural tobacco take the centre stage while baking spice, sweetness, and pepper recede to the back. It's a peculiar order which is also incredibly replayable.

Retrohale carries a sweet balance of natural tobacco sweetness and pinches of salt upon a wave of buttery goodness. The strength is a little on the heavy medium side. I have nothing to complain about the burn or the ash. In my book, this is what a cigar experience should be like.

Final Third

Hallo! Here is a new note, cedar. I squeal like a 5-year old girl because honestly this cigar is perfectly balanced as is and I didn't expect anything new. Cedar brought a friend, maple syrup and cocoa tagged along. I am curious to see how these new characters will play with the existing crew.

Much to my delight, the other notes namely baking spice, caramel, white pepper, cinnamon, dry fruit and natural tobacco sweetness intensify. The earth and natural tobacco notes that were in the front of the palate through the mid third also step up to the play. Now there is a sweet symphony of flavour notes that prance proudly throughout the remainder of my stick.

This was one heck of a smoke. At closing, the strength was teetering on a medium-full but not quite full. Flavour was certainly at full which is all I care about at this point.

Final Thoughts

Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Nicaragua is worth every minute. I am glad that renowned reviewers like Cigar Aficionado agree. CA gave this baby a deserving 92 rating as well as a slot in the Top 25 cigars of 2020.