Subscribe & Save 5% on hundreds of items!

Top Premium Cigars

Top Premium Cigars

At Gotham Cigars, our Top Premium Cigars are like the "all-star" team of cigars! Made from the very best tobacco and rolled with special care, these cigars are perfect for anyone who loves a smooth and rich smoke. If you want a really special cigar that’s high-quality and made to impress, check out our top picks and enjoy the best smoking experience.

Read more
  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Oliva Serie V Melanio Torpedo Open Box and Stick Oliva Serie V Melanio Torpedo Stick

    Oliva Serie V Melanio Torpedo

    Size: 5 x 58
    $178.00
    $139.99
     The Oliva Serie V Melanio line was an instant success when it was originally launched at the 2012 IPCPR Trade Show. Since 2012, cigar aficionados have given countless rave reviews including numerous 90+ ratings. The Oliva Serie V Melanio line pays...
    $178.00
    $139.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $178.00
    $139.99
    Subtotal:
  • Padron 1926 Serie 80 Years Maduro
    Size: 6 3/4 x 54
    $288.80
    $269.99
    Padron 1926 Serie 80 Years Maduro is an incredible 96 rated and Top 25 Cigars originally created to celebrate the 75th birthday of Jose Padron. Celebrating such a milestone is worthy of only the finest cigar, which is what the famed 1926 serie has...
    $288.80
    $269.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $288.80
    $269.99
    Subtotal:
  • Padron 1926 Series No. 2 Maduro Box and Stick Padron 1926 Series No. 2 Maduro Four Pack
    Size: 5 1/2 x 52
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Padron Cigars here. Padron 1926 Series No. 2 Maduro Four Pack features four cigars from the very exclusive 1926 anniversary blend. These cigars are produced in very...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Padron Executive Natural Padron Executive Natural Stick
    Size: 7 1/5 x 50
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Padron Cigars here. Padron Executive Natural is a bold and refined cigar crafted for those who appreciate a rich and complex smoking experience! Wrapped in a...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • White Owl Cigarillos Maple Bourbon Box with Pouch White Owl Cigarillos Maple Bourbon Box Front

    White Owl Cigarillos Maple Bourbon

    Size: 4 5/8 x 28
    $37.50
    $33.99
    The White Owl Cigarillos Maple Bourbon (Limited Edition) brings together smooth bourbon notes and rich maple sweetness for a one-of-a-kind, aromatic experience. Each cigarillo is crafted with the signature White Owl blend, delivering a mellow, flavorful...
    $37.50
    $33.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $37.50
    $33.99
    Subtotal:
  • Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro Box of 10 and stick Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro stick
    Size: 6 x 52
    $137.90
    $119.99
    Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro Box of 10 is a 96 rated masterpiece that was awarded cigar of the year in 2019. This Nicaraguan puro features the finest tobaccos from the infamous AJ Fernandez factory which are hand rolled and box pressed to...
    $137.90
    $119.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $137.90
    $119.99
    Subtotal:
  • Alec Bradley MAXX Nano

    Alec Bradley MAXX Nano

    Size: 4 x 46
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Alec Bradley Cigars here. Alec Bradley MAXX Nano is a bold and expertly crafted cigar, designed for those who enjoy deep complexity and smooth refinement. Wrapped in a...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente Hemingway Masterpiece box and stick Arturo Fuente Hemingway Masterpiece stick
    Size: 9 x 52
    $201.10
    $179.99
    Arturo Fuente Hemingway Masterpiece exudes elegance with its extra long format and has earned an incredible 92 rating. Each cigar is hand rolled to perfection with aged Dominican fillers and binder draped in a rare African Cameroon wrapper. The result is...
    $201.10
    $179.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $201.10
    $179.99
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Work of Art Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Work of Art Box

    Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Work of Art

    Size: 4 7/8 x 62
    $220.00
    $119.99
    Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Work of Art is a rare and powerful full-bodied, perfecto shaped cigar handmade in the Dominican Republic in limited quantities. This powerhouse of a blend features tobaccos grown on the Fuente family farms in the...
    $220.00
    $119.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $220.00
    $119.99
    Subtotal:
  • CAO Italia Ciao open box and stick CAO Italia Ciao stick

    CAO Italia Ciao

    Size: 5 x 56
    Please note this item is no longer available. Please find our huge selection of CAO Cigars here. CAO Italia Ciao is a 92 rated, full bodied smoke. Featuring a four country blend with Peruvian, Nicaraguan and Italian tobacco grown in the Benevento...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Cuban Rounds Natural Robusto Pack with Stick Cuban Rounds Natural Robusto Srick
    Size: 5 x 50
    $57.60
    $37.99
    The Cuban Rounds Natural Robusto offers a classic Cuban-style experience in a smooth and flavorful 5 x 50 format. Handcrafted in Nicaragua, these cigars feature a rich blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos wrapped in a silky natural leaf, delivering a...
    $57.60
    $37.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $57.60
    $37.99
    Subtotal:
  • Dutch Masters Cigarillos Tropical Box and Pouch Dutch Masters Cigarillos Tropical Pouch
    Size: 4 1/2 x 28
    $38.70
    $33.79
    The Dutch Masters Cigarillos Tropical deliver a burst of fruity sweetness in every puff. Blended with premium natural tobaccos and infused with tropical fruit flavor, these cigarillos offer a mellow and aromatic smoke that’s both smooth and...
    $38.70
    $33.79
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $38.70
    $33.79
    Subtotal:
  • Joya Black Toro Open Box and Stick Joya Black Toro Stick

    Joya Black Toro

    Size: 6 x 52
    Please note this item is no longer made. Find our selection of Joya de Nicaragua Cigars here.   Joya de Nicaragua introduces the Joya Black Toro featuring a rich blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos wrapped in the Mexican San Andres Negra leaf, a first...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • La Aroma de Cuba Rothschild Open Box and Stick La Aroma de Cuba Rothschild Stick

    La Aroma de Cuba Rothschild

    Size: 4 1/2 x 50
    Now: $38.77 - $139.08
     La Aroma de Cuba Rothchild is the original La Aroma de Cuba blend and has earned over a dozen 90+ ratings since its debut and a spot on the Top 25 Cigars of the Year twice, so far. This blend features perfectly aged Nicaraguan fillers and binder...
    Now: $38.77 - $139.08
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $38.77 - $139.08
    Subtotal:
  •  Padron Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro open box and stick  Padron Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro stick
    Size: 5 x 54
    Now: $141.75 - $275.50
    Padron Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro is a magnificent blend of meticulously hand crafted cigars once reserved exclusively for the Padron family. This highly sought after blend was crowned #1 Cigar of the Year and has earned an incredible 94 rating. These...
    Now: $141.75 - $275.50
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $141.75 - $275.50
    Subtotal:
  • Ramon Allones Habano Torpedo open box and stick Ramon Allones Habano Torpedo stick

    Ramon Allones Habano Torpedo

    Size: 6 1/2 x 54
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of AJ Fernandez Cigars here. Ramon Allones Habano Torpedo features a unique blend of perfectly aged tobaccos. Featuring an aged Corojo '99 binder and a mix of aged...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Rocky Patel Grand Reserve Sixty Open Box and Stick Rocky Patel Grand Reserve Sixty Stick
    Size: 6 x 60
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Rocky Patel Cigars here. Rocky Patel Grand Reserve Sixty features a proprietary blend of Rocky Patel's oldest tobaccos that have been aged an additional two years...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente Don Arturo Destino Siglo Amistad Open Box and Stick
    Size: 5 x 50
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente Cigars here. Arturo Fuente Don Arturo Destino Siglo Amistad is a premium cigar crafted to celebrate the Fuente family’s dedication to excellence...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente Flor Fina 858 Box Of 10
    Size: 4 1/2 x 33
    $100.00
    $79.99
    Arturo Fuente Flor Fina 858 is an 87 rated blend featuring an African Cameroon wrapper draped over a Dominican core. The roll is nice and the seams, well, you almost can’t even see them. The draw is just right. Like all Arturo Fuente cigars, the...
    $100.00
    $79.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $100.00
    $79.99
    Subtotal:
  • Ashton Symmetry Prism open box and stick Ashton Symmetry Prism open box

    Ashton Symmetry Prism

    Size: 5 5/8 x 46
    Now: $74.47 - $352.35
    Ashton Symmetry Prism is a luxurious smoke deserving of a special place in your humidor. The result of a collaboration between Ashton and living legend Carlito Fuente, this proprietary blend utilizes ultra rare tobaccos and is the first Ashton to feature...
    Now: $74.47 - $352.35
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $74.47 - $352.35
    Subtotal:
  • Davidoff Signature Exquisitos Open Box
    Size: 3 5/8 x 22
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Davidoff Cigars here. Davidoff Signature Exquisitos has earned an incredible 91 rating and delivers an elegant balance and refinement, even with its small ring...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Deadwood Dominicana Gordo Box with Stick Deadwood Dominicana Gordo Stick
    Size: 6 x 60
    $135.00
    $106.99
    The Deadwood Dominicana Gordo is a larger, 6 × 60 size cigar that offers a smooth and mellow experience. Handcrafted in Nicaragua by Drew Estate, it features an Ecuador-grown Connecticut Shade wrapper, a Mexican San Andrés binder, and...
    $135.00
    $106.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $135.00
    $106.99
    Subtotal:
  • Deadwood Girl With No Name Lonsdale Box and Stick
    Size: 7 x 44
    $220.00
    $197.99
    Deadwood Girl With No Name is the newest vixen to join the legendary lineup of the Deadwood Tobacco Company, including fan favorites like Fat Bottom Betty and Crazy Alice. This cigar measures an impressive 7 x 44, wrapped in a rich Mexican San...
    $220.00
    $197.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $220.00
    $197.99
    Subtotal:
  • H. Upmann the Banker Daytrader Toro H. Upmann the Banker Daytrader Toro Stick
    Size: 6 x 54
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of H. Upmann Cigars here. H. Upmann the Banker Daytrader Toro is a modern expression of the famous Banker brand and the first New Money release. These medium bodied...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Joya Red Robusto open box Joya Red Robusto Stick

    Joya Red Robusto

    Size: 5 1/4 x 50
    Please note this item is no longer made. Find our selection of Joya de Nicaragua Cigars here. The Joya Red Robusto was designed to engage the contemporary aficionado’s desire for an extremely pleasing smoke. A masterfully blended Nicaraguan filler...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Laranja Reserva Toro

    Laranja Reserva Toro

    Size: 6 x 52
     Please Note: This product is no longer manufactured. Please check out our selection of Premium Cigars here. Laranja Reserva Toro is as delicious as it is beautiful. The surprising orange hue of the Brazilian wrapper is the inspiration for...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Liga Privada Papa Fritas Ashtray + Lighter Liga Privada Papa Fritas Lighter
    Size: x
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Cigar Super Bundles here. Enjoy a complete smoking setup with the Liga Privada Papa Fritas Ashtray + Lighter Combo. This premium set includes a stylish ashtray...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Opus DUBAI Viento D'Amor
    Size: 6 x 58
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente Cigars here. Arturo Fuente Opus X 2020 Viento d'Amor is a beautiful Medium-Full bodied Toro Gordo shaped cigar made using the finest tobacco in the...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Padron 1964 Anniversary Sampler Maduro Box Front Padron 1964 Anniversary Sampler Maduro Box

    Padron 1964 Anniversary Sampler Maduro

    Size: Varies x Varies
    Temporarily Unavailable Padron is a renowned for excellence. To celebrate their success they released the 1964 Anniversary Series in 1994 on their 30 year anniversary. Perfectly aged 4 year premium Nicaraguan tobaccos and is encased in a decadent...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Padron 1964 Anniversary Soberano Tubos Padron 1964 Anniversary Soberano Tubos
    Size: 5 x 50
    $313.50
    $289.99
    Padron 1964 Anniversary Soberano Tubos are 90 rated cigars that were ranked the #3 cigar of 2020.  The 1964 Anniversary blend is one of the most exclusive in the Padron portfolio, created to commemorate the 30th anniversary of the famed brand...
    $313.50
    $289.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $313.50
    $289.99
    Subtotal:
  • Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve Barrel Fermented Toro Open Box and Stick Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve Barrel Fermented Toro  Stick

    Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve Barrel Fermented Toro

    Size: 6 x 52
    Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve Barrel Fermented Toro is handcrafted in small batches in Esteli, Nicaragua by Drew Estate. The first wrapper is a Kentucky seed, Kentucky grown tobacco which is then fire cured in the traditional Kentucky style and then...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Nicaragua Toro Open Box and Stick Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Nicaragua Toro Stick
    Size: 6 x 54
    Now: $49.03 - $224.99
    Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Nicaragua Torois a 6 x 54 Nicaraguan puro made with hand selected tobaccos from AJ Fernandez's estate in Esteli. This medium to full bodied blend exudes notes of cedar, almonds, raisins and leather with a woody finish. It's...
    Now: $49.03 - $224.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $49.03 - $224.99
    Subtotal:
  • San Christobal Elegancia Churchill Open Box and Stick San Christobal Elegancia Churchill Stick
    Size: 7 x 50
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Ashton Cigars here. San Cristobal Elegancia Churchill is a gorgeous 91 rated blend featuring premium Nicaraguan fillers and binder from the Garcia family estates...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • On Sale
    Tyson 2.0 Undisputed Maduro 7 x 60 box Tyson 2.0 Undisputed Maduro 7 x 60 stick
    Size: 7 x 60
    $288.50
    $298.50
    Tyson 2.0 Undisputed Maduro 7 x 60 is a bold, full-bodied cigar that delivers knockout flavor with every puff! Wrapped in a dark and oily Maduro wrapper, this cigar is packed with aged Nicaraguan long-fillers, offering deep notes of dark chocolate,...
    $288.50
    $298.50
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $288.50
    $298.50
    Subtotal:
  • Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Impromptu Box of 10 box and stick Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Impromptu stick
    Size: 6 1/2 x 54
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our selection of Aging Room Cigars here. Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Impromptu Box of 10 is a Nicaraguan puro that has earned an incredible 96 rating. Crafted in Nicaragua by AJ...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente A Father and His Son Cutter Edition open box Arturo Fuente A Father and His Son Cutter Edition

    Arturo Fuente A Father and His Son Cutter Edition

    Size: Varies x Varies
    Arturo Fuente A Father and His Son Cutter Edition features a rare selection of exclusive Opus X cigars and cutter. This sampler includes: 2 x Don Carlos Personal Reserve  2 x OpusX Destino Al Siglo Robusto  1 x Cutter
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Happy Ending Box Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Happy Ending Box

    Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Happy Ending

    Size: 5 1/2 x 53
    $260.71
    $149.99
    Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Happy Ending is a rare and powerful perfecto shaped cigar handmade in the Dominican Republic in limited quantities. This powerhouse of a blend features tobaccos grown on the Fuente family farms in the Dominican...
    $260.71
    $149.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $260.71
    $149.99
    Subtotal:
  • Ashton Symmetry Sublime open box and stick Ashton Symmetry Sublime open box
    Size: 6 x 52
    Now: $79.90 - $379.50
    Indulge in the luxury of Ashton Symmetry Sublime Cigars, expertly crafted to deliver a perfectly balanced and flavorful smoking experience. These premium cigars feature a unique blend of Dominican and Nicaraguan long-fillers wrapped in a silky Ecuadorian...
    Now: $79.90 - $379.50
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $79.90 - $379.50
    Subtotal:
  • Cohiba Nicaragua N4x45 3-Pack

    Cohiba Nicaragua 3 Pack

    Size: 4 x 45
    $46.20
    Cohiba Nicaragua is the newest addition to the Cohiba line of cigars made in Nicaragua. These cigars feature Honduran Colorado Claro wrapper, a Nicaraguan binder, and Nicaraguan long–fillers from Estelí and Jalapa. They are medium to full...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $46.20
    Subtotal:
  • Deadwood Dominicana Toro Box with Stick Deadwood Dominicana Toro Stick
    Size: 6 x 50
    $125.00
    $99.99
    The Deadwood Dominicana Toro is a smooth and flavorful Toro cigar (6 × 50) made in Nicaragua. It’s wrapped in silky Connecticut Shade leaf, uses a Mexican San Andrés binder, and features Dominican fillers that shine through every puff...
    $125.00
    $99.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $125.00
    $99.99
    Subtotal:
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

At Gotham Cigars, our Top Premium Cigars are like the "all-star" team of cigars! Made from the very best tobacco and rolled with special care, these cigars are perfect for anyone who loves a smooth and rich smoke. If you want a really special cigar that’s high-quality and made to impress, check out our top picks and enjoy the best smoking experience.

Read more