• Follow Me on Pinterest
Register
All
Now In: Home / Cigars / Top Cigars Rated 90+
Check Out Our Humidors
Store Rating
Gotham Cigars is rated 4.8/5 based on more than 8100 votes.

Top Cigars Rated 90+

Top Cigars Rated 90+ are carefully reviewed considering factors such as the cigar's appearance, construction, and the way it smokes. Other central factors of top cigars rated 90+ are the aromas or flavors and the balance of these various characteristics that give the cigar its overall taste. Cigar Aficionado magazine reviews thousands of cigars by a panel of experts on premium handmade cigars from all around the world. Find a great selection of top cigars rated 90+ bellow.

Tin Cigars
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 View All
Reviews
Image
Description
Our Price
BHROB

Rated 5.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Brick House Robusto
Brick House Robusto
Quantity: 25 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 x 54

You save 7% at Gotham Cigars
Item is currently on backorder
Note: Items purchased on backorder usually arrive in-house 1-7 days for shipping.
$115.80
Quantity:
Add to Cart
DCDROB

Rated 1.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Double Robusto
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Double Robusto
Quantity: 25 cigars /box
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 3/4 x 52

You save 13% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$218.30
Quantity:
Add to Cart
PAD3N

Rated 4.0 by

2 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Padron 3000 Natural
Padron 3000 Natural
Quantity: 26 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 1/2 x 52

You save 30% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$131.26
Quantity:
Add to Cart
LGCHUR

Rated 4.5 by

2 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

La Gloria Cubana Churchill
La Gloria Cubana Churchill
Quantity: 25 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 7 x 50

You save 40% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$108.29
Quantity:
Add to Cart
RPV92CHR

Rated 5.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Rocky Patel Vintage 1992 Churchill
Rocky Patel Vintage 1992 Churchill
Quantity: 20 Cigars
Size: 7 x 48
Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra Seed
Binder: Mexico
Filler: Dominican & Nicaraguan
Strength: Medium Bodied

You save 15% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$151.95
Quantity:
Add to Cart
OLVSVBEL

Rated 2.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Oliva Serie V Belicoso
Oliva Serie V Belicoso
Quantity: 24 Cigars
Wrapper: Habano Sun-Grown
Size: 5 x 54

You save 19% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$125.95
Quantity:
Add to Cart
LGWAV

Rated 4.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

La Gloria Cubana Wavell
La Gloria Cubana Wavell
Quantity: 25 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 x 50

You save 40% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$89.81
Quantity:
Add to Cart
LAFINCOR

Rated 0.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

La Finca Corona
La Finca Corona
Quantity: 20 Cigars Bundle
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 1/2 x 42

You save 55% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$33.75
Quantity:
Add to Cart
CAMCFIG

Rated 4.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Camacho Corojo Figurado
Camacho Corojo Figurado
Quantity: 25 cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 54 x 42 x 6 1/2

You save 37% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$111.75
Quantity:
Add to Cart
AFCHAT

Rated 4.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Arturo Fuente Chateau Fuente
Arturo Fuente Chateau Fuente
Quantity: 20 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 4 1/2 X 50

In Stock & Ready to Ship
$91.20
Quantity:
Add to Cart
ABPRCHR

Rated 4.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill
Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill
Quantity: 20 Cigars
Size: 7 x 48
Wrapper: Natural

You save 15% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$173.95
Quantity:
Add to Cart
ASHCOR

Rated 3.9 by

4 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Ashton Corona
Ashton Corona
Quantity: 25 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 1/2 x 44

You save 15% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$154.69
Quantity:
Add to Cart
AFDCHAT

Rated 4.3 by

4 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Arturo Fuente Double Chateau
Arturo Fuente Double Chateau
Quantity: 20 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 6 3/4 x 50

You save 8% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$110.00
Quantity:
Add to Cart
CAOBRAGOL

Rated 4.7 by

4 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

CAO Brazilia Gol
CAO Brazilia Gol
Quantity: 20 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 x 56

You save 35% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$88.93
Quantity:
Add to Cart
AFROTH

Rated 5.0 by

3 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Arturo Fuente Rothschild
Arturo Fuente Rothschild
Quantity: 25 cigars /box
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 4 1/2 X 50

You save 13% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$99.50
Quantity:
Add to Cart
PAD2N

Rated 4.4 by

2 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Padron 2000 Natural
Padron 2000 Natural
Quantity: 26 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 x 50

You save 28% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$115.50
Quantity:
Add to Cart
GETOR

Rated 4.5 by

2 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Gurkha Evil Toro
Gurkha Evil Toro
Quantity: 20 cigars /box
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 6 x 50

You save 25% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$125.95
Quantity:
Add to Cart
TEMINC

Rated 5.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Tempus Inceptio
Tempus Inceptio
Quantity: 20 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 5 5/8 x 46

You save 17% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$144.95
Quantity:
Add to Cart
SOPASS

Rated 5.0 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

CAO Sopranos Associate
CAO Sopranos Associate
Quantity: 20 Cigars
Wrapper: Dark Natural
Size: 5 x 52

You save 37% at Gotham Cigars
Item is currently on backorder
Note: Items purchased on backorder usually arrive in-house 1-7 days for shipping.
$142.13
Quantity:
Add to Cart
PAD4N

Rated 4.7 by

1 Reviewer(s)

Add Your Review

Padron 4000 Natural
Padron 4000 Natural
Quantity: 26 Cigars
Wrapper: Natural
Size: 6 1/2 x 54

You save 25% at Gotham Cigars
In Stock & Ready to Ship
$175.14
Quantity:
Add to Cart
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 View All 

        	

         
                

    

    

             
    
  

  



 
                



  

    

      

        

          
        

        

          
        

        

          
        

      

      

      

        
      

    

    

      

          
    
                
  • SHOP WITH CONFIDENCE
    • 
                
  • Gotham Cigars is an Upfront Merchant on TheFind. Click for info.
    • 
          
        
    • 
        
  •  
       
    •