When you hear rare, exotic, and limited you quickly think expensive, classy, aristocratic...

And yes, there are rare, highly sought-after smokes that people are willing to queue for, bid for, and pay an arm and a leg for.

For a cigar to qualify as rare, it has to be quite exquisite. At Gotham Cigars, we have an impressive display of rare cigars that you ought to save for special occasions. Our rare cigar collection is sourced from all the top names in the industry. You will recognize most of the makers but there are a few surprises as well.

What to Buy

You may need to brace yourself because some of the cigars here are truly cigars you’ve never heard of.

But some will be familiar brands fronting high-end blends. Though they may be expensive, they are worth every penny.

Our first exquisitely rare cigar is Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve Barrel Fermented Toro, a handcrafted piece that comes in small volumes from Esteli, Nicaragua by the Drew Estate. 

In addition, we have Padron Family Reserve No 50 Natural, a majestic piece that was named Cigar of the Year with a rating of 92. This full bodied stick is made of pure Nicaraguan tobacco and wrappers that have been aged for about 10 years. 

If you’re a Cohiba person, feast yourself on Cohiba Churchill and Cohiba Corona both medium-bodied and absolutely delightful.

Montecristo also makes some incredibly extravagant stogies. You have your Montecristo White Churchill, Montecristo Classic Collection No. 2 Box Pressed, and Montecristo White No. 2 just to mention a few.

If you’ve never had a superlatively crafted Ashton, then you’re in good company. Grab yourself  Ashton Monarch Tubes and Ashton Cabinet No.7 to get a taste of true refinement.

Final Words

These are not all the rare cigars; it’s a small fraction of  a vast portfolio. To shop for these and more rare cigars, visit us at gothamcigars.com.