Subscribe & Save 5% on hundreds of items!

Shop by Price per Cigar

Shop by Price per Cigar

At Gotham Cigars, we make it easy to shop by price per cigar so you can find the perfect smoke that fits your budget. Whether you're looking for an affordable everyday option or a special treat, we’ve got a range of cigars to suit every price point. From budget-friendly picks to premium selections, explore our collection and enjoy the best cigars at the right price for you.

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Fourth Down Super Bundle Romeo y Julieta 1875 Bully 5 Pack
    Add to Cart
    Quick view

    Fourth Down Super Bundle

    Size: Varies x Varies
    $107.10
    $70.00
    Don't punt on this deal! Fourth Down Super Bundle is the perfect assortment of five packs to hand out to friends while watching the game! This bundle includes four five packs and is valued at $141.05! Fourth Down Super Bundle includes: 5 x...
    $107.10
    $70.00
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $107.10
    $70.00
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Game Leaf White Chocolate Box
    Add to Cart
    Quick view
    Size: 4 1/2 x 27
    $17.99
    If you love sweet and smooth flavors, you’ll enjoy Game Leaf White Chocolate cigars. These cigars are wrapped in a natural leaf and filled with a rich white chocolate flavor, making each puff taste creamy and delicious. With every smoke,...
    $17.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $17.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Baccarat Toro OpeN Box and Stick Baccarat Toro Stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Baccarat Toro

    Size: 6 x 50
    Now: $23.99 - $99.99
    Baccarat Toro cigars are smooth, creamy, and full of rich tobacco flavor. Made with high-quality Honduran fillers and a golden Connecticut wrapper, they provide a slow, even burn and an easy draw for a relaxing smoke.   Each cigar is 6 inches long...
    Now: $23.99 - $99.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $23.99 - $99.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Out of stock
    White Owl Cigarillos Blackout Berry box and foilpack White Owl Cigarillos Blackout Berry box
    Quick view
    Size: 4 5/8 x 28
    $35.70
    $29.99
    Limited Edition White Owl Blackout Berry Cigarillos have a rich blend of berry featuring mild strength and a natural leaf wrapper for a smooth smoking experience. Crafted in the USA, these cigarillos offer a perfect fusion of quality tobacco and...
    $35.70
    $29.99
    Out of stock Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $35.70
    $29.99
    Subtotal:
    Out of stock
  • Back Alley Cigarillos Blue Vanilla Back Alley Cigarillos Blue Vanilla foil pack
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Back Alley Cigarillos Blue Vanilla

    Size: 4 1/2 x 27
    Now: $18.99 - $19.99
    Back Alley Cigarillos Blue Vanilla are a new and exciting cigarillo made in the Dominican Republic using a blend of carefully aged tobaccos rolled in a natural homogenized leaf wrapper.  The fillers undergo a premium infusion process which adds...
    Now: $18.99 - $19.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $18.99 - $19.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Avo Classic No. 9 Open Box and Stick Avo Classic No. 9 Stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Discover the Elegance of AVO Classic No. 9 Cigars

    Size: 4 3/4 x 48
    Now: $47.99 - $175.99
    AVO Classic No. 9 is a cigar designed for those who appreciate smoothness, balance, and elegance in every puff. Crafted with expertly aged Dominican tobaccos and wrapped in a silky Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper, this mild-bodied cigar offers a refined...
    Now: $47.99 - $175.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $47.99 - $175.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Backwoods Cognac XO Barrel open box Backwoods Cognac XO Barrel
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Backwoods Cognac XO Barrel

    Size: 4 1/8 x 27
    Now: $56.95 - $59.95
    The Backwoods Cognac XO Barrel cigars are a luxurious choice for smokers who appreciate rich and bold flavors. Infused with the smooth essence of fine cognac, these rustic cigars deliver a sophisticated and satisfying smoking experience.   Crafted...
    Now: $56.95 - $59.95
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $56.95 - $59.95
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Deadwood Sweet Jane Tins Deadwood Sweet Jane Tins
    Choose Options
    Quick view
    Size: 4 x 32
    Now: $77.89 - $81.99
    The Deadwood Sweet Jane Tins by Drew Estate offer a delightful smoking experience in a compact size. These cigars are crafted with premium tobaccos and infused with a sweet and aromatic flavor profile that’s perfect for any occasion...
    Now: $77.89 - $81.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $77.89 - $81.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Tatiana La Vita Vanilla Box and Stick Tatiana La Vita Vanilla Stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Tatiana La Vita Vanilla

    Size: 5 x 38
    Now: $17.99 - $69.99
    Tatiana La Vita Vanilla is a smooth and flavorful cigar infused with the rich, creamy essence of vanilla. Made with high-quality Cuban-seed tobaccos and wrapped in a silky Dominican wrapper, this cigar offers a mellow yet indulgent smoking experience...
    Now: $17.99 - $69.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $17.99 - $69.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Dark Horse Filtered Cigars Cherry Box Dark Horse Filtered Cigars Cherry Pack
    Choose Options
    Quick view
    Size: 3 7/8 x 20
    Now: $16.14 - $16.99
    Dark Horse Filtered Cigars Cherry are smooth, fruity, and packed with bold cherry flavor. Made with high-quality tobacco, they burn slowly and evenly, giving you a deliciously sweet and satisfying smoke.   With a rich cherry taste and a smooth...
    Now: $16.14 - $16.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $16.14 - $16.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Out of stock
    Quorum Maduro Double Gordo Bundle Quorum Maduro Double Gordo Bundle and Stick
    Quick view
    Size: 6 x 60
    $76.40
    $55.39
    The Quorum Maduro Double Gordo is meticulously hand-crafted in Nicaragua and uses the finest ingredients straight from the source. Its Nicaraguan fillers and binder  in a gorgeous Maduro shade wrapper gives an aromatic medium-bodied smoke, leaving...
    $76.40
    $55.39
    Out of stock Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $76.40
    $55.39
    Subtotal:
    Out of stock
  • Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona open box and stick Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona

    Size: 5 1/4 x 45
    Now: $33.73 - $148.65
    Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona is a smooth and classic cigar that never goes out of style! Crafted with premium Dominican tobacco, this cigar delivers a mellow and flavorful smoking experience.   Wrapped in a silky Natural leaf, it offers notes...
    Now: $33.73 - $148.65
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $33.73 - $148.65
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Padron 2000 Maduro Open Box and Stick Padron 5000 Maduro Stick
    Add to Cart
    Quick view
    Size: 5 1/2 x 56
    $259.99
    Padron 5000 Maduro is a premium full-bodied cigar crafted for those who appreciate deep, complex flavors with a smooth finish. Wrapped in a dark and oily Nicaraguan Maduro wrapper, this expertly aged cigar delivers bold notes of cocoa, espresso, and...
    $259.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $259.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Baccarat Panatela open box and stick Baccarat Panatela open box
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Baccarat Panatela

    Size: 6 x 38
    Now: $21.99 - $89.99
    Baccarat Panatela cigars are smooth, creamy, and have a sweet taste. Made with high-quality Honduran tobacco and a light brown Connecticut Shade wrapper, they burn evenly and are easy to smoke.   Each cigar is 6 inches long with a ring gauge of...
    Now: $21.99 - $89.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $21.99 - $89.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Optimo Cigarillos Blue Box Optimo Cigarillos Blue Pack
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Optimo Cigarillos Blue

    Size: 4 x 30
    Now: $26.59 - $27.99
    Optimo Cigarillos Blue are machine made cigars with high quality tobacco fillers and all natural leaf wrapper, with no additional flavors. These cigars are a milder smoke that are naturally smooth with natural tobacco flavor and a mellow aroma Each box...
    Now: $26.59 - $27.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $26.59 - $27.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Tatiana Classic Cherry Open Box and Stick Tatiana Classic Cherry Stick
    Add to Cart
    Quick view

    Tatiana Classic Cherry

    Size: 6 x 44
    $124.99
    $79.95
    Tatiana Classic Cherry are wonderfully sweet cigars hand rolled with Cuban seed Dominican tobacco fillers that have been infused with the sweet essence of cherry oils and aged for two years. These delightfully smooth cigars are then wrapped in a...
    $124.99
    $79.95
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $124.99
    $79.95
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Arturo Fuente Exquisito Open Box and Stick Arturo Fuente Exquisito Stick
    Add to Cart
    Quick view

    Arturo Fuente Exquisito

    Size: 4 1/2 x 33
    $150.00
    $126.51
    Arturo Fuente Exquisito is a small cigar that packs a lot of flavor. Hand-rolled in the Dominican Republic, it uses high-quality Dominican tobacco for both the filler and binder, all wrapped in a Cameroon wrapper.   This cigar measures 4 1/2...
    $150.00
    $126.51
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $150.00
    $126.51
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Good Times Sweet Woods Strawberry Cream - Box with Single Pouch Good Times Sweet Woods Strawberry Cream - Box
    Add to Cart
    Quick view
    Size: 4 1/4 x 27
    $20.29
    The Good Times Sweet Woods Strawberry Cream cigars are perfect for smokers who enjoy a sweet and fruity flavor. Infused with the delicious taste of strawberry cream, these cigars deliver a smooth and satisfying smoking experience.   Made with...
    $20.29
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $20.29
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Tatiana Mini Tins Chocolate Box Tatiana Mini Tins Chocolate Pack
    Choose Options
    Quick view
    Size: 3 1/2 x 26
    Now: $56.99 - $59.99
    Tatiana Mini Tins Chocolate offers a smooth, sweet, and decadent smoking experience in a convenient mini size. Infused with the rich flavor of premium chocolate, these mini cigars deliver a bold yet balanced taste with a naturally sweet and creamy finish...
    Now: $56.99 - $59.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $56.99 - $59.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Good Times Sweet Woods Diamond Box Good Times Sweet Woods Diamond Pouch
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Good Times Sweet Woods Diamond

    Size: 4 1/4 x 30 1/4
    $30.00
    $20.29
    Good Times Sweet Woods Diamond delivers notes of chocolatey cream with hints of liquor and sweet tobacco. Curated and crafted in the Dominican Republic, these mild bodied cigarillos offer a harmonious blend of flavors that reflect the Dominican...
    $30.00
    $20.29
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $30.00
    $20.29
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Nub Connecticut 460 open box and stick Nub Connecticut 460 stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Nub Connecticut 460

    Size: 4 x 60
    $53.47
    $19.99
    Nub Connecticut 460 delivers a smooth and flavorful smoking experience in a short yet satisfying size! Wrapped in a silky Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper, this cigar features aged Nicaraguan long-fillers, creating a creamy, mellow profile with notes of...
    $53.47
    $19.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $53.47
    $19.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Out of stock
    Quorum Classic Toro Quorum Classic Toro Bundle and Stick
    Quick view
    Size: 6 x 50
    Now: $40.77 - $42.92
    The Quorum Classic Toro is a smooth and flavorful cigar that’s great for anyone who loves a rich, bold smoke. Made in Nicaragua, these cigars are hand-rolled using high-quality tobacco, giving them a slow, even burn and an easy draw.   Each...
    Now: $40.77 - $42.92
    Out of stock Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $40.77 - $42.92
    Subtotal:
    Out of stock
  • Alec Bradley Black Market Robusto 5 Pack
    Add to Cart
    Quick view

    Alec Bradley Black Market Robusto 5 Pack

    Size: 5 1/4 x 52
    $46.75
    $19.99
    Alec Bradley Black Market Robusto 5 Pack is a bold and expertly crafted collection designed for those who enjoy a full-bodied smoking experience. Wrapped in a dark and oily Nicaraguan wrapper, these premium cigars deliver deep, satisfying flavors with...
    $46.75
    $19.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $46.75
    $19.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • CAO World Sampler II CAO World Sampler II Sticks
    Add to Cart
    Quick view
    Size: Varies x Varies
    $30.80
    $27.99
    The CAO World Sampler II takes you on a flavorful journey with some of the best cigars from CAO’s world-renowned blends. This premium sampler features a variety of cigars, each crafted with quality tobacco from different regions, offering a unique...
    $30.80
    $27.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $30.80
    $27.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Macanudo Inspirado Minis Orange Macanudo Inspirado Minis Orange Pack
    Choose Options
    Quick view
    Size: 3 x 20
    Now: $52.24 - $54.99
    Introducing Macanudo Inspirado Orange Minis! These little cigars feature the same blend as the full size cigar but in a convenient smaller size for taking anywhere you go. The Inspirado Orange collection features a blend of Dominican Olor, Nicaraguan...
    Now: $52.24 - $54.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $52.24 - $54.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Arturo Fuente Churchill Maduro box and stick Arturo Fuente Churchill Maduro stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Arturo Fuente Churchill Maduro

    Size: 7 1/4 x 48
    Now: $39.42 - $177.10
    Arturo Fuente Churchill Maduro is the perfect choice if you love bold flavor with a smooth finish! Handcrafted with premium Dominican tobacco, this cigar is wrapped in a rich, dark Maduro leaf for a deep and satisfying smoke.   With notes of...
    Now: $39.42 - $177.10
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $39.42 - $177.10
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Arturo Fuente Seleccion D'Oro Corona Imperial Open Box and Stick Arturo Fuente Seleccion D'Oro Corona Imperial Stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Arturo Fuente Seleccion D'Oro Corona Imperial

    Size: 6 1/2 x 46
    Now: $36.89 - $164.45
    Arturo Fuente Selección D'Oro Corona Imperial cigar is a smooth and mild smoke that's perfect for those who enjoy a gentle cigar. It's made in the Dominican Republic with high-quality Dominican fillers and binder, all wrapped in a light...
    Now: $36.89 - $164.45
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $36.89 - $164.45
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Dutch Masters Cigarillos Sweet Fusion Dutch Masters Cigarillos Sweet Fusion Foil Pack
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Dutch Masters Cigarillos Sweet Fusion

    Size: 4 3/4 x 28
    Now: $32.10 - $33.79
    Treat yourself to the rich, sweet flavor of Dutch Masters Cigarillos Sweet Fusion. These premium cigarillos are made with high-quality tobacco and infused with a unique blend of sweet flavors, delivering a smooth and enjoyable smoking experience...
    Now: $32.10 - $33.79
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $32.10 - $33.79
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Macanudo Inspirado Minis White box Macanudo Inspirado Minis White pack
    Choose Options
    Quick view
    Size: 3 x 20
    Now: $52.24 - $54.99
    Introducing Macanudo Inspirado White Minis! The mini, hand rolled cigars feature the same blend of Mexican San Andres and Nicaraguan tobaccos that have been aged for four years and an Ecuadorian Connecticut leaf wrapper that has been aged for six years...
    Now: $52.24 - $54.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $52.24 - $54.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Padron 2000 Natural Open Box and Stick Padron 2000 Natural Stick
    Add to Cart
    Quick view
    Size: 5 x 50
    $254.37
    $199.99
    Padron 2000 Natural cigars are known for their high-quality blend of mature Cuban-seed tobaccos that give you an incredible smoking experience. They are encased in home-grown Nicaraguan leaf wrappers that perfectly complement the taste of the tobacco...
    $254.37
    $199.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $254.37
    $199.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Partagas Black Label Clasico Open Box and Stick Partagas Black Label Clasico Stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Partagas Black Label Clasico

    Size: 5 1/4 x 54
    Now: $46.49 - $169.99
    The Partagas Black Label Clasico is a premium cigar designed for those who enjoy a bold, full-bodied smoking experience. Handcrafted with a dark, oily Maduro wrapper and rich tobaccos, this cigar delivers deep, complex flavors with notes of espresso,...
    Now: $46.49 - $169.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $46.49 - $169.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Montecristo Ultimate Bundle Montecristo-White-Rothschild---5-Pack
    Add to Cart
    Quick view
    Size: Varies x Varies
    $241.20
    $79.99
    Montecristo Ultimate Bundle features one five pack from each of Montecristo's top blends. Montecristo White Rothchild features a blend of Dominican and Nicaraguan fillers draped in an Ecuadorian wrapper with woody flavors and notes of maple syrup in a...
    $241.20
    $79.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $241.20
    $79.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Out of stock
    Romeo Y Julieta Reserve Titan Open Box and Stick Romeo Y Julieta Reserve Titan stick
    Quick view

    Romeo Y Julieta Reserve Titan Cigars

    Size: 6 x 54
    $236.67
    $169.99
    Romeo y Julieta Reserve Titan Cigars are perfect for anyone who loves a bold and flavorful smoke. Made with premium Nicaraguan tobacco, these cigars have a rich, full-bodied taste that’s smooth and satisfying.   They’re crafted with...
    $236.67
    $169.99
    Out of stock Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $236.67
    $169.99
    Subtotal:
    Out of stock
  • Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur No. I Maduro open box and stick Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur No. I Maduro stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur No. I Maduro

    Size: 7 1/4 x 54
    Now: $44.29 - $160.99
    Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur No. I Maduro delivers a bold, full-bodied smoking experience with deep, complex flavors! Wrapped in a dark, oily Maduro leaf, this cigar offers rich notes of espresso, dark chocolate, and spice, creating a smooth yet intense...
    Now: $44.29 - $160.99
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $44.29 - $160.99
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Brick House Mighty 4 Cigar Sampler Closed Box Brick House Mighty 4 Cigar Sampler Open Box
    Add to Cart
    Quick view

    Brick House Mighty 4 Cigar Sampler

    Size: Varies x Varies
    $30.00
    $28.99
    Brick House Mighty 4 Cigar Sampler features a sampling of the best sticks from the Brick House brand. These Nicaraguan puros are meticulously crafted and feature the brand's signature blend of Nicaraguan fillers that give the blends their unique flavors...
    $30.00
    $28.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $30.00
    $28.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Factory Throwouts No.59 Natural Bundle
    Choose Options
    Quick view
    Size: 6 1/4 x 45
    Now: $30.70 - $32.32
    Factory Throwouts No.59 Natural by J.C. Newman features high quality tobaccos you love about their cigars at a fraction of the cost. They feature slightly discolored tobaccos and a Cuban-Sandwich style core with a mix of long and short fillers that...
    Now: $30.70 - $32.32
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $30.70 - $32.32
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Deadwood Crazy Alice Short Pyramid Open Box and Stick Deadwood Crazy Alice Short Pyramid Stick
    Add to Cart
    Quick view

    Deadwood Crazy Alice Short Pyramid

    Size: 4 x 46
    $85.00
    $68.99
    The Deadwood Crazy Alice Short Pyramid cigar is a one-of-a-kind creation from Drew Estate that combines bold flavors with a unique design. Known for its short pyramid shape and rich aromatic profile, Crazy Alice is a standout choice for cigar enthusiasts...
    $85.00
    $68.99
    Add to Cart Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $85.00
    $68.99
    Subtotal:
    Add to Cart
  • Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller Open Box and Stick Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller Stick
    Choose Options
    Quick view

    Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller

    Size: 4 1/2 x 55
    Now: $39.73 - $178.65
    Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller cigar is a rich and flavorful smoke that's great for anyone who enjoys a medium-strength cigar. It's made in the Dominican Republic with high-quality Dominican fillers and binder, all wrapped in a beautiful Cameroon...
    Now: $39.73 - $178.65
    Choose Options Quick view
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $39.73 - $178.65
    Subtotal:
    Choose Options
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

At Gotham Cigars, we make it easy to shop by price per cigar so you can find the perfect smoke that fits your budget. Whether you're looking for an affordable everyday option or a special treat, we’ve got a range of cigars to suit every price point. From budget-friendly picks to premium selections, explore our collection and enjoy the best cigars at the right price for you.