Subscribe & Save 5% on hundreds of items!

Top Premium Cigars

Top Premium Cigars

At Gotham Cigars, our Top Premium Cigars are like the "all-star" team of cigars! Made from the very best tobacco and rolled with special care, these cigars are perfect for anyone who loves a smooth and rich smoke. If you want a really special cigar that’s high-quality and made to impress, check out our top picks and enjoy the best smoking experience.

Read more
  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Out of stock
    Punch Signature Rothschild open box and stick Punch Signature Rothschild stick

    Punch Signature Rothschild

    Size: 4 1/2 x 50
    $142.02
    $110.78
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our selection of Punch Cigars here.  Punch Signature Rothschild is a 90 rated blend hailing from Honduras. Featuring a distinct blend of vintage tobaccos from the Dominican Republic and...
    $142.02
    $110.78
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $142.02
    $110.78
    Subtotal:
  • Romeo y Julieta Book of Love Open Box and Stick Romeo y Julieta Book of Love Stick
    Size: 6 x 52
    $136.20
    $117.00
    Romeo y Julieta Book of Love is a limited-edition blend paying homage to the star-crossed lovers for which the brand is named. Presented in a beautiful box resembling a book, each contains 10 toro sized cigars measuring 6 x 52. These medium-full bodied...
    $136.20
    $117.00
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $136.20
    $117.00
    Subtotal:
  • Aging Room Quattro Nicaraguan Concerto Open box and stick Aging Room Quattro Nicaraguan Concerto stick

    Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Concerto

    Size: 7 x 50
    Now: $62.75 - $234.99
    The Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Concerto is a premium cigar crafted for those who appreciate bold and complex flavors. Named Cigar of the Year, this masterpiece is made entirely from 100% Nicaraguan tobaccos, showcasing the richness and depth of...
    Now: $62.75 - $234.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $62.75 - $234.99
    Subtotal:
  • Alec Bradley Coyol Belicoso Alec Bradley Coyol Belicoso

    Alec Bradley Coyol Belicoso

    Size: 5 1/2 x 58
    Please note this item is no longer made. Find our selection of Alec Bradley Cigars here. The Alec Bradley Coyol Belicoso is the latest Alec Bradley cigar made at the Raices Cubanas factory in Danli, Honduras. Alec Bradley Cigars have been producing some...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Short Story Front View Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Short Story Side View

    Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Short Story

    Size: 4 x 49
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente Cigars here. Arturo Fuente Rare Pink Vintage 1960's VS Short Story is a rare and powerful perfecto shaped cigar handmade in the Dominican Republic in limited...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Ashton Cabinet No. 1 Box and Stick Ashton Cabinet No. 1 Stick
    Size: 9 x 52
    $248.50
    $228.38
    Ashton Cabinet No. 1 is a smooth and expertly crafted cigar, designed for those who enjoy a mellow yet flavorful smoking experience. Wrapped in a silky Connecticut Shade wrapper, this premium cigar delivers a rich, creamy profile with every draw...
    $248.50
    $228.38
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $248.50
    $228.38
    Subtotal:
  • Ashton Symmetry Belicoso open box and stick Ashton Symmetry Belicoso open box
    Size: 5 1/4 x 52
    Now: $77.73 - $368.65
    Ashton Symmetry Belicoso is a luxurious blend that rightfully earned a 94 rating. This proprietary blend features rare Dominican tobacco blended with Nicaraguan tobaccos, a first for the Ashton brand. The wrapper is a gorgeous Ecuadorian Habano Rosado...
    Now: $77.73 - $368.65
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $77.73 - $368.65
    Subtotal:
  • Ashton Symmetry Robusto open box and stick Ashton Symmetry Robusto open box
    Size: 5 x 50
    Now: $76.43 - $362.15
    Ashton Symmetry Robusto is the result of a collaboration between Ashton and Carlito Fuente years in the making. This proprietary blend is the first Ashton to feature Nicaraguan tobaccos. Nicaraguan tobaccos are masterfully blended with Dominican tobacco...
    Now: $76.43 - $362.15
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $76.43 - $362.15
    Subtotal:
  • Blackened M81 Corona Doble open box with stick Blackened M81 Corona Doble  stick
    Size: 7 x 50
    Now: $52.25 - $193.00
    95 rating and #7 Cigar of the Year 2023! Blackened M81 Corona Doble by Drew Estate was a special collaboration between a few well-known cigar enthusiasts – Jonathan Drew, James Hetfield and Rob Dietrich and has earned an incredible 95 rating...
    Now: $52.25 - $193.00
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $52.25 - $193.00
    Subtotal:
  • CAO Flathead V642 Piston open box and stick CAO Flathead V642 Piston stick

    CAO Flathead V642 Piston

    Size: 6 1/2 x 42
    $293.70
    $209.99
    CAO Flathead V642 Piston embodies everything you could want in a bold cigar. Inspired by girls and retro hot rods, these box pressed beauties are definitely worthy of a spot in your humidor. This blend features aged Nicaraguan long fillers and...
    $293.70
    $209.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $293.70
    $209.99
    Subtotal:
  • CAO Pilon Churchill Open Box and Stick CAO Pilon Churchill Stick
    Size: 7 x 48
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of CAO Cigars here. The CAO Pilon Churchill features a binder and long fillers from Nicaragua that have been through the Pilon method of fermentation, giving them a rich...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Diamond Crown Maximus Double Corona No. 1 Rated b 93 by Cigar Aficionado Diamond Crown Maximus Double Corona No. 1 stick

    Diamond Crown Maximus Double Corona No. 1

    Size: 8 x 50
    Robust to the core, Diamond Crown Maximus Double Corona No. 1 cigars are not for the faint of heart. The Diamond Crown Maximus is a premium cigar line that was conceived by the Newman family of the US and created with the help of the Fuente family from...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Enclave Broadleaf Robusto Box and Stick Enclave Broadleaf Robusto Stick

    Enclave Broadleaf Robusto

    Size: 5 x 52
    Now: $40.13 - $144.52
    AJ Fernandez Enclave Broadleaf Robusto is a 5 x 52 full bodied smoke. This cigar features a select blend of Piloto Cubano and aged Nicaraguan long fillers draped with Nicaraguan binder and an oily Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper. This exceptional smoke...
    Now: $40.13 - $144.52
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $40.13 - $144.52
    Subtotal:
  • Joya Silver Ultra Box and Stick Joya Silver Ultra Stick

    Joya Silver Ultra

    Size: 6 1/4 x 46
    Please note this item is no longer made. Find our selection of Joya de Nicaragua Cigars here. Joya Silver Ultra is a 61/4 x 46 Corona Extra featuring Nicaraguan long fillers, a Mexican binder and a dark Ecuadorian leaf wrapper. The finished stogie is a...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    Liga Privada No. 9 Belicoso open Box and stick Liga Privada No. 9 Belicoso Stick

    Liga Privada No. 9 Belicoso

    Size: 6 x 52
    $444.00
    $377.40
    Liga Privada No 9 Belicoso are premium hand rolled, medium to full bodied cigars made in limited production, originally created for the president of Drew Estates himself to enjoy. These impeccably constructed cigars are filled with a premium blend of...
    $444.00
    $377.40
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $444.00
    $377.40
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    Liga Privada T52 Petit Corona  Box and Stick Liga Privada T52 Petit Corona  Stick

    Liga Privada T52 Petit Corona

    Size: 4 1/4 x 46
    $258.00
    $247.67
    Liga Privada T52 Petit Corona is a bold and flavorful cigar that delivers an intense yet smooth smoking experience. Handcrafted with a rich blend of Nicaraguan and Honduran tobaccos, this full-bodied cigar is wrapped in a dark, oily stalk-cut Habano...
    $258.00
    $247.67
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $258.00
    $247.67
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    Liga Privada T52 Sampler Box Liga Privada T52 Sampler Box

    Liga Privada T52 Sampler

    Size: Various x Various
    $80.00
    $64.75
    Liga Privada T52 Sampler is a premium collection designed for those who enjoy bold, full-bodied cigars with rich complexity and smooth refinement. This sampler features a handpicked selection of expertly aged cigars, ensuring a luxurious smoking...
    $80.00
    $64.75
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $80.00
    $64.75
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    Liga Privada Unico Serie Dirty Rat Box Liga Privada Unico Serie Dirty Rat Box

    Liga Privada Unico Serie Dirty Rat

    Size: 5 x 44
    $216.00
    $183.60
    Liga Unico Dirty Rat is the first cigar in the Unico series produced by Drew Estates. The size of the cigar is specific to the flavor notes and is only available as a Corona. The Dirty Rat is a complex blend utilizing a Connecticut sun grown Habana...
    $216.00
    $183.60
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $216.00
    $183.60
    Subtotal:
  • My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Stick

    My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo

    Size: 6 x 52
    Now: $56.82 - $254.99
    My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo is a full bodied, box-pressed beauty. This blend earned cigar of the year for it's masterful blending of aged Nicaraguan long fillers and binder. The real jewel of this blend is the dark Ecuadorian Habano leaf wrapper...
    Now: $56.82 - $254.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $56.82 - $254.99
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    Opus X Angel's Share Perfecxion X Tin Box and sticks Opus X Angel's Share Perfecxion X Tin box

    Opus X Angel's Share Perfecxion X Tin

    Size: 6 1/4 x 48
    $139.95
    $118.90
    This item is temporarily unavailable. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente cigars here. Opus X Angel's Share Perfecxion X Tin contains three of the rarest cigars from one of world's best rated brands, Opus X. These exclusive and...
    $139.95
    $118.90
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $139.95
    $118.90
    Subtotal:
  • Opus X Angel's Share Reserva D'Chateau Tin Opus X Angel's Share Reserva D'Chateau Tin Box

    Opus X Angel's Share Reserva D'Chateau Tin

    Size: 7 x 48
    This item is temporarily unavailable. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente cigars here. Opus X Angel's Share Reserva D'Chateau Tin features three ultra premium cigars in an attractive case. The cigars are Dominican puros utilizing a...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    Opus X Angel's Share Robusto Tin Opus X Angel's Share Robusto Tin box

    Opus X Angel's Share Robusto Tin

    Size: 5 1/4 x 50
    $129.95
    $107.95
    This item is temporarily unavailable. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente cigars here. Opus X Angel's Share Robusto Tin features three exemplary cigars that have been rated a very high 88 by Cigar Aficionado. The term...
    $129.95
    $107.95
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $129.95
    $107.95
    Subtotal:
  • Opus X Love Affair

    Opus X Love Affair

    Size: 4 1/2 x 52
    This item is temporarily unavailable. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente cigars here. Opus X Love Affair is a full bodied Dominican puro featuring an exquisite Colorado maduro wrapper. This 4 1/2 x 52 perfecto was made to honor Carlos...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    OpusX Oro Oscuro Super Belicoso 4 pack OpusX Oro Oscuro Super Belicoso 4 pack and stick
    Size: 5 1/2 x 52
    $139.73
    OpusX Oro Oscuro Super Belicoso is an ultra-premium blend made in extremely limited quantities. These rare cigars are considered among the best in the world. These full bodied, Dominican puros feature a proprietary blend of Dominican long fillers...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $139.73
    Subtotal:
  • Quarterback's 25 Premium Picks Bundle Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Nicaragua Toro 5 Pack
    Size: Varies x Varies
    $369.30
    $240.04
    Get ready for the big game with Quarterback's 25 Premium Picks Bundle! Quarterback's 25 Premium Picks Bundle contains:   Gurkha Beast  (Retail value: $101.40) Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Nicaragua Toro 5 Pack (Retail value: $64...
    $369.30
    $240.04
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Quantity:
    Price:
    $369.30
    $240.04
    Subtotal:
  • Trinidad Espiritu Toro Open Box and Stick Trinidad Espiritu Toro 5 pack with stick
    Size: 6 x 54
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our selection of Montecristo White Cigars here.  Trinidad Espiritu Toro is a 94 rated blend created by master tobacconist AJ Fernandez to celebrate the famed brand's 50th anniversary and...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Acid 20 Toro 10 Pack Bundle
    Size: 6 x 50
    Please note this bundle is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Cigar Super Bundles here. Acid 20 Toro 10 Pack Bundle features a five pack of Acid 20 Toro Natural and Acid 20 Toro Maduro at a great discounted price. Acid 20 Toro by...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill open box and stick Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill

    Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill

    Size: 7 x 48
    Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill is an exquisite and highly rated blend. The Prensado blend features a premium blend of Nicaraguan, Honduran and Trojes long filler tobaccos draped in a Trojes Corojo leaf wrapper. The construction is impeccable and the...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Alec Bradley Tempus Nicaragua Magnus Box and Stick Alec Bradley Tempus Nicaragua Magnus Stick

    Alec Bradley Tempus Nicaragua Magnus

    Size: 6 x 60
    Alec Bradley Tempus Nicaragua Magnus has earned a high rating of 90, and it’s understandable why. This Nicaraguan puro features a select blend of premium long fillers from the Jalapa, Esteli and Condega regions as well as double binders. The...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Alec Bradley Tempus Terra Novo 5 Pack Alec Bradley Tempus Terra Novo Stick

    Alec Bradley Tempus Terra Novo

    Size: 5 x 50
    Alec Bradley Tempus Terra Nova is another medium to full bodied cigar from the flagship Tempus line of Alec Bradley cigars."Tempus" indicates the time it takes for a quality cigar such as this one to fully develop from a tobacco seed to a...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Maduro Box and Stick Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Maduro Single Cigar

    Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Maduro

    Size: 4 x 49
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our huge selection of Arturo Fuente Cigars here. Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Maduro is a medium-bodied, figurado shaped cigar that has earned an incredible 91 rating. Featuring...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Flatbush The Doorman Gordo bundle Flatbush The Doorman Gordo stick
    Size: 6 x 60
    Now: $37.99 - $39.99
    Flatbush The Doorman Gordo is a medium to full bodied cigar featuring a two region blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos from the fertile soils of Condega and Jalapa and a Nicaraguan Habano binder. The finishing touch is an oily Ecuadorian...
    Now: $37.99 - $39.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $37.99 - $39.99
    Subtotal:
  • H Upmann 1844 Classic Robusto box and stick H Upmann 1844 Classic Robusto stick
    Size: 5 x 52
    Now: $38.77 - $173.84
    H. Upmann 1844 Classic Robusto offers a smooth and creamy smoking experience, perfect for those who enjoy a well-balanced cigar! Wrapped in a silky Ecuadorian Connecticut leaf, this cigar features notes of toasted almonds, cedar, vanilla, and a hint of...
    Now: $38.77 - $173.84
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $38.77 - $173.84
    Subtotal:
  • Joya Silver Robusto  Box and Stick Joya Silver Robusto Stick

    Joya Silver Robusto

    Size: 5 x 50
    Please note this item is no longer made. Find our selection of Joya de Nicaragua Cigars here. Joya Silver Robusto features an exclusive blend to commemorate the brand's 50th anniversary of producing exquisite cigars in Nicaragua. Featuring Nicarguan...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Joya Silver Toro Box Joya Silver Toro Stick

    Joya Silver Toro

    Size: 6 x 52
    Please note this item is no longer made. Find our selection of Joya de Nicaragua Cigars here. Joya Silver Toro is a 6 x 52 vitola featuring a blend of Nicaraguan long filler tobaccos, Mexican binder and a dark, reddish brown Ecuadorian leaf wrapper...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Magnifico Open Box and Stick La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Magnifico Stick
    Size: 6 x 52
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our selection of Ashton Cigars here. La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Magnifico is a luxurious, full-bodied blend that has earned over a dozen 90+ ratings, an incredible 95 rating in May 2023, Top 25...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • La Aroma de Cuba Reserva Divino box and stick La Aroma de Cuba Reserva Divino stick

    La Aroma de Cuba Reserva Divino

    Size: 6 1/2 x 52
    Please note this product is no longer available. Check out our selection of La Aroma de Cuba Cigars here. La Aroma de Cuba Reserva Divino is a delectable 94 rated blend that also earned top 25 cigar of the year in 2013. Made with the finest...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Laranja Reserva Corona Gorda Laranja Reserva Corona Gorda Stick

    Laranja Reserva Corona Gorda

    Size: 5 5/8 x 46
    Please note this item is no longer made. Find our selection of Espinosa Cigars here.   The Laranja Reserva Corona Gorda is the perfect size stick in this exceptional line of cigars from the famous cigar maker Espinosa. Immediately you will notice...
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Subtotal:
  • Out of stock
    Liga Privada T52 Toro Tubo Open Box and Stick Liga Privada T52 Toro Tubo Open Box and Tube

    Liga Privada T52 Toro Tubo

    Size: 6 x 52
    $169.50
    $146.81
    Liga Privada T52 Toro Tubo is a bold and expertly crafted cigar, designed for those who enjoy a rich, full-bodied smoking experience. Wrapped in a dark and oily Connecticut Habano leaf, this premium cigar delivers intense and satisfying flavors with...
    $169.50
    $146.81
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    $169.50
    $146.81
    Subtotal:
  • Montecristo Nicaragua Toro  Box and Stick Montecristo Nicaragua Toro  Stick

    Montecristo Nicaragua Toro

    Size: 6 x 54
    Now: $70.29 - $264.99
    Montecristo Nicaragua Toro is a bold and expertly crafted cigar, perfect for those who appreciate a full-bodied smoking experience. Made entirely from the finest Nicaraguan tobaccos, this premium cigar delivers deep and complex flavors with notes of...
    Now: $70.29 - $264.99
    Qty in Cart: 0
    Price:
    Now: $70.29 - $264.99
    Subtotal:
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

At Gotham Cigars, our Top Premium Cigars are like the "all-star" team of cigars! Made from the very best tobacco and rolled with special care, these cigars are perfect for anyone who loves a smooth and rich smoke. If you want a really special cigar that’s high-quality and made to impress, check out our top picks and enjoy the best smoking experience.

Read more