90+ Rated Cigars
Gotham Cigars features a vast selection of premium and super premium hand made cigars Top Rated 90+ by Cigar Aficionado, the premier cigar and lifestyle magazine. Each cigar reviewed by their editors is meticulously critiqued on several factors including the cigar's appearance, construction, smoking characteristics and overall impression.
Other central factors of top cigars rated 90+ are the aromas or flavors and the balance of these various characteristics that give the cigar its overall taste. Cigar Aficionado magazine reviews thousands of cigars by a panel of experts on premium handmade cigars from around the world. The premium cigars that are honored with a 90+ rating are the crème de la crème. Find a great selection of top premium cigars rated 90+ including Gurkha Cellar Reserve, Padron, Arturo Fuente, and more. These cigars are a must have for any serious cigar smoker's humidor.
Read moreIn life we rate everything; cars, hotels, products, electronics, everything! We do the same for cigars too. Needless to say, as far as cigars go, you want a cigar with a high rating.
Renowned authorities in the cigar world like CA use the 1-100 rating criteria with 100 being the highest rated. Other reviewers use 1-5 with 5 being the highest rate. When we are talking about 90+ rated cigars, we mean the highest rated cigars in the industry.
In truth, there’s no cigar that ever clocked 100 rating seeing that there’s a lot of factors to consider. Cigars are rated based on many factors including intensity, construction, flavor profile, ash, smoke output, finish, draw, balance, and consistency just to mention a few.
There was only one Hoyo de Monterrey that got a mind-boggling 99 rating in 1992. Let us now explore the top rated cigars so you can shop intelligently.
90+ Rated Cigars
As for cigars with a 97 rating you find our beloved My Father Le Bijou 1922 Box Pressed Torpedo which clinched Cigar of the Year in 2015.
There are quite a number of cigars with a 96 rating thus far. You have your Alec Bradley Prensado, Cohiba Robusto, Flor De Las Antillas, Oliva Serie V Melanio, Padron Series 1926, Punch Double Corona, and Montecristo No. 2.
Some outstanding smokes with a 95 rating include Aging Room Quattro, CAO Flathead V660 Carb, Punch Punch and Rocky Patel Sun Grown among many more.
Now, a majority of 90+ rated cigars fall below the 95 rating. And we have an absolutely delicious collection of these cigars. Ashton is one of the top cigar manufacturers with top rated Dominican smokes including Ashton Corona and Ashton 898.
CAO also makes award winning cigars. So, it is no surprise that there’s a bunch of 90+ rated cigars in its portfolio including CAO Brazilia Gol and CAO Colombia Bogotá.
When you hear the name AJ Fernandez, you know excellence follows it. And that is precisely why Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Bully and Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto are here.
Kaizad Hansotia is a legend on these streets. Thanks to his incredible taste, Gurkha Cellar Reserve Limitada 15 Year Solara makes this prestigious list.
Punch cigars are quite common in the top percentile list. We’ve already featured Punch Punch and now we’re adding more Punch Cigars with 90+ rating namely Punch London Club and Punch After Dinner.
Other legendary mouth-watering smokes in this category include Partagas Cortado Toro, Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur No. 1, Macanudo Inspirado Orange
Partagas #10, and Rocky Patel Sun Grown.
Refine by
Browse by Brand, Please Select & more Hide Filters Show FiltersBrand
Please Select
Price
Length
Shape
Filler
- Colombian, Brazilian (1)
- Colombian, Dominican (1)
- Colombian, Mexican, Nicaraguan (1)
- Condega, Honduras, Jalapa, San Andres (1)
- Connecticut River Valley Broadleaf Maduro (1)
- Dominican (26)
- Dominican, Honduran, Nicaraguan (2)
- Dominican, Mexican (5)
- Dominican, Nicaraguan (13)
- Dominican, Nicaraguan, Honduran (1)
Origin
Strength
Wrapper
Gotham Cigars features a vast selection of premium and super premium hand made cigars Top Rated 90+ by Cigar Aficionado, the premier cigar and lifestyle magazine. Each cigar reviewed by their editors is meticulously critiqued on several factors including the cigar's appearance, construction, smoking characteristics and overall impression.
Other central factors of top cigars rated 90+ are the aromas or flavors and the balance of these various characteristics that give the cigar its overall taste. Cigar Aficionado magazine reviews thousands of cigars by a panel of experts on premium handmade cigars from around the world. The premium cigars that are honored with a 90+ rating are the crème de la crème. Find a great selection of top premium cigars rated 90+ including Gurkha Cellar Reserve, Padron, Arturo Fuente, and more. These cigars are a must have for any serious cigar smoker's humidor.
Read moreIn life we rate everything; cars, hotels, products, electronics, everything! We do the same for cigars too. Needless to say, as far as cigars go, you want a cigar with a high rating.
Renowned authorities in the cigar world like CA use the 1-100 rating criteria with 100 being the highest rated. Other reviewers use 1-5 with 5 being the highest rate. When we are talking about 90+ rated cigars, we mean the highest rated cigars in the industry.
In truth, there’s no cigar that ever clocked 100 rating seeing that there’s a lot of factors to consider. Cigars are rated based on many factors including intensity, construction, flavor profile, ash, smoke output, finish, draw, balance, and consistency just to mention a few.
There was only one Hoyo de Monterrey that got a mind-boggling 99 rating in 1992. Let us now explore the top rated cigars so you can shop intelligently.
90+ Rated Cigars
As for cigars with a 97 rating you find our beloved My Father Le Bijou 1922 Box Pressed Torpedo which clinched Cigar of the Year in 2015.
There are quite a number of cigars with a 96 rating thus far. You have your Alec Bradley Prensado, Cohiba Robusto, Flor De Las Antillas, Oliva Serie V Melanio, Padron Series 1926, Punch Double Corona, and Montecristo No. 2.
Some outstanding smokes with a 95 rating include Aging Room Quattro, CAO Flathead V660 Carb, Punch Punch and Rocky Patel Sun Grown among many more.
Now, a majority of 90+ rated cigars fall below the 95 rating. And we have an absolutely delicious collection of these cigars. Ashton is one of the top cigar manufacturers with top rated Dominican smokes including Ashton Corona and Ashton 898.
CAO also makes award winning cigars. So, it is no surprise that there’s a bunch of 90+ rated cigars in its portfolio including CAO Brazilia Gol and CAO Colombia Bogotá.
When you hear the name AJ Fernandez, you know excellence follows it. And that is precisely why Romeo Y Julieta 1875 Bully and Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto are here.
Kaizad Hansotia is a legend on these streets. Thanks to his incredible taste, Gurkha Cellar Reserve Limitada 15 Year Solara makes this prestigious list.
Punch cigars are quite common in the top percentile list. We’ve already featured Punch Punch and now we’re adding more Punch Cigars with 90+ rating namely Punch London Club and Punch After Dinner.
Other legendary mouth-watering smokes in this category include Partagas Cortado Toro, Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur No. 1, Macanudo Inspirado Orange
Partagas #10, and Rocky Patel Sun Grown.